Florida homeowners are once again feeling the squeeze as thousands are being removed from the state-run insurer of last resort, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, and redirected to private carriers. The move is part of an ongoing effort to reduce the size of Citizens’ policy portfolio and shift risk back into the private market.

When homeowners are “depopulated” from Citizens, they are required to accept coverage from an alternative private insurance company if the offered premium is within 20% of their Citizens rate. For many, this creates both relief and frustration: while it means they may avoid losing coverage altogether, it also leaves them with limited options and rising costs.

“I was paying $2,800 a year with Citizens, and the new carrier came in at $3,200. It’s technically within the 20% rule, so I had no choice but to move,” said one Tampa homeowner. “It feels like a forced decision at a time when the market is already tough.”

Insurance analysts note that while the depopulation program helps reduce taxpayer exposure to catastrophic hurricane losses, it places additional pressure on families already navigating skyrocketing premiums, stricter underwriting, and fewer choices. Private carriers, however, argue that they offer more sustainable long-term solutions than Citizens, which was never intended to be a permanent insurer for a large share of the market.

State regulators defend the process, emphasizing that the 20% price window is meant to strike a balance between protecting consumers from steep cost increases while encouraging participation in the private market. Without this system, they warn, Citizens could swell beyond capacity, putting all Floridians at risk of paying hefty assessments after a major storm.

Still, homeowners are left in a difficult position. With hurricane season stretching until November and reinsurance costs continuing to climb, experts say Florida’s property insurance crisis is far from over. For many, the decision isn’t whether they want to leave Citizens—it’s how they can afford to stay insured at all.

About the Author:

David Dandaneau is a client relations analyst that covers the insurance and financial services industry. He is known for his insightful analysis and comprehensive coverage of market trends and regulatory developments.